融合教育背景下特殊教育的认同危机与发展理路反思*

教育科学 ›› 2023, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (1): 62-68.

融合教育背景下特殊教育的认同危机与发展理路反思^*

于松梅

辽宁师范大学教育学院,辽宁大连 116029

出版日期:2023-01-15 发布日期:2023-03-10
作者简介:于松梅(1968- ),女,辽宁大连人,辽宁师范大学教育学院教授,教育学博士,主要从事特殊儿童心理与教育、残疾人社会学研究。
基金资助:
中国高等教育学会特殊教育研究分会“特殊教育研究”2021年度课题“融合教育背景下随班就读学生社会参与质量研究”(21ZSTSJYYB02)

Identity Crisis and Reflection on the Development of Special Education Under the Background of Inclusive Education

Yu Songmei

School of Education,Liaoning Normal University,Dalian Liaoning 116029,China

Online:2023-01-15 Published:2023-03-10

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

受后现代主义哲学和文化思潮影响,融合教育成为全球特殊教育的发展趋势。从隔离到融合的变迁给现代主义范式下的传统特殊教育带来困惑与未知感,特殊教育在发展过程中因受到融合教育的冲击而面临认同危机。本研究以史为鉴,审视特殊教育认同危机背后的历史文化脉络,致力于纠正融合安置地点而非教学成为特殊教育的关注焦点,以及淡化残疾与其他人类差异的差异性等错误认识。本研究还就我国特殊教育发展的基本理路进行反思,强调特殊教育学界需要深入体认自身学科在教学上的“特殊性”本质。面向未来,我国特殊教育发展需基于国情和社会文化土壤,探索具有中国特色、有效、负责任的融合教育之路。

关键词: 融合教育, 随班就读, 特殊教育, 认同危机

Abstract:

Influenced by postmodernist philosophy and cultural trends, inclusive education has become the development trend of global special education. The transition from isolation to inclusion has brought confusion and a sense of unknown to traditional special education under the paradigm of modernism,and special education is facing an identity crisis due to the impact of integration education in the development process. Using history as a mirror,this study examines the historical and cultural context behind the identity crisis in special education,and aims to correct misconceptions such as inclusion placement rather than teaching as the focus of special education,and downplaying the differences between disabilities and other human differences. This study also reflects on the basic rationale for the development of special education in China,emphasizing that the special education academic circle needs to deeply understand the“special”nature of its own discipline in teaching. Facing the future,the development of special education in China needs to be based on national conditions and social and cultural soils,and explore an effective and responsible way of inclusive education with Chinese characteristics.

Key words: inclusive education, learning in regular class, special education, identity crisis

中图分类号:

G760

于松梅. 融合教育背景下特殊教育的认同危机与发展理路反思^*[J]. 教育科学, 2023, 39(1): 62-68.

Yu Songmei. Identity Crisis and Reflection on the Development of Special Education Under the Background of Inclusive Education[J]. Education Science, 2023, 39(1): 62-68.

参考文献 33

[1]	于松梅, 杨雨卉. “Special Education”一词在美国诞生的历史溯源[J]. 绥化学院学报, 2022(10):122-125.
[2]	MEYEN E L, SKRTIC T M. Special education and student disability:traditional, emerging, and alternative perspectives[M]. Denver, Co: Love, 1995:1.
[3]	王雁, 朱楠. 70年的跨越:特殊教育学学科发展[J]. 教育研究, 2019(10):27-40.
[4]	赵斌, 张瀚文. 建党一百年来中国特殊教育发展成就[J]. 中国特殊教育, 2021(8):7-12.
[5]	李拉. 融合教育学的建构:融合教育理论研究专题(五)[J]. 现代特殊教育, 2021(10):8-12.
[6]	颜廷睿. 特殊教育并不“特殊”:关于特殊教育“特殊性”的思考[J]. 现代特殊教育, 2016(5):71-77.
[7]	黄勇. 融合教育让“特殊学生”不再特殊[C]. 国家教师科研专项基金科研成果(神州教育第5卷), 2014:249.
[8]	WINZER M A. The history of special education: from isolation to integration[M]. Washington DC: Gallaudet University Press, 1993:363-365.
[9]	WINZER M A. From integration to inclusion: a history of special education in the 20th century[M]. Washington DC: Gallaudet University Press, 2009:202-206.
[10]	LIEBERMAN L M. Special education and regular education: a merger made in heaven?[J]. Exceptional children, 1985(51):513-516.
[11]	KIUPPIS F. Why (not) associate the principle of inclusion with disability? Tracing connections from the start of the ‘Salamanca Process’[J]. International journal of inclusive education, 2013(7):746-761.
[12]	KAUFFMAN J M. How we might achieve the radical reform of special education[J]. Exceptional children, 1993(1):6-16.
[13]	李芳, 邓猛. 全纳教育的后现代性分析[J]. 外国教育研究, 2009(2):16-19.
[14]	ZIGMOND N. Where should students with disabilities receive special education services? Is one place better than another?[J]. The journal of special education, 2003(3):193-199.
[15]	KAUFFMAN J M, BADAR J. Instruction, not inclusion, should be the central issue in special education: an alternative view from the USA[J]. Journal of international special needs education, 2014(1):13-20.
[16]	景时. 融合教育后现代差异观的阐释与批判[J]. 中国特殊教育, 2021(4):14-19.
[17]	LORD C, CHARMAN T, HAVDAHL A, et al. The lancet commission on the future of care and clinical research in autism[J]. The Lancet, 2022(10321):271-334.
[18]	AINSCOW M, BOOTH T, DYSON A, et al. Improving schools, developing inclusion[M]. London: Routledge, 2006:14-27.
[19]	GÖRANSSON K, NILHOLM C. Conceptual diversities and empirical shortcomings: a critical analysis of research on inclusive education[J]. European journal of special needs education, 2014(3):265-280.
[20]	庞文. 改革开放以来我国融合教育的演进脉络、经验反思与未来展望[J]. 残疾人研究, 2020(4):51-60.
[21]	FLORIAN L. Special or inclusive education: future trends[J]. British journal of special education, 2008(4):202-208.
[22]	WARNOCK M. Special education needs: a new look[M]∥TERZI L. Special education needs:a new look. London: Continuum, 2010:11-45.
[23]	GURALNICK M J, NEVILLE B, HAMMOND M A, et al. The friendships of young children with developmental delays: a longitudinal analysis[J]. Journal of applied developmental psychology, 2007(1):64-79. pmid: 17558442
	[ 24 WARNOCK M. Special education needs: a new look[M]∥TERZI L. Special education needs:a new look. London: Continuum, 2010:11-45.
[25]	HEWARD W L. Exceptional children:an introduction to special education (9th edition)[M]. New Jersey: Pearson Education Upper Saddle River, 2009:35-41.
[26]	KIRK S A. What is special about special education? The child who is mentally handicapped[J]. Exceptional children, 1953(19):138-142.
[27]	FUCHS D, FUCHS L S. What’s “special” about special education?[J]. Phi delta kappan, 1995(7):522-533.
[28]	COOK B G, SCHIRMER B R. What is special about special education? Overview and analysis[J]. The journal of special education, 2003(3):200-205.
[29]	HORNBY G. Inclusive special education: evidence-based practices for children with special needs and disabilities[M]. New York: Springer, 2014:12-13.
[30]	朴永馨. 努力发展有中国特色的特殊教育学科[J]. 现代特殊教育, 2017(6):3-5.
[31]	KAUFFMAN J M. How we might achieve the radical reform of special education[J]. Exceptional children, 1993(1):6-16.
[32]	GERBER M M. Postmodernism in special education[J]. The journal of special education, 1994, 28(3):368-378. doi: 10.1177/002246699402800310
[33]	杨茹, 赵彬, 王雁. 教师对融合教育的理解与践行:基于社会学新制度主义的分析[J]. 教师教育研究, 2020(4):96-103.