教育科学 ›› 2025, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (3): 81-88.

• 比较教育研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

韩国英才教育正当性论争及其回应*——基于《第五次英才教育振兴综合计划(2023—2027年)》的分析

梁荣华   

  1. 东北师范大学 教育学部, 吉林 长春 130024
  • 出版日期:2025-05-15 发布日期:2025-06-10
  • 作者简介:梁荣华(1981- ),男,辽宁盘锦人,东北师范大学教育学部副教授,博士生导师,北京师范大学国际与比较教育研究院兼职研究员,主要从事比较教育研究。
  • 基金资助:
    *教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地重大项目“高质量教育体系建设的国际比较与中国的战略选择研究”(22JJD880006)

The Debate over the Legitimacy of Gifted and Talented Education in the Republic of Korea and Its Responses—An Analysis Based on the Fifth Comprehensive Plan for the Revitalization of Gifted and Talented Education (2023—2027)

Liang RongHua   

  1. Faculty of Education,Northeast Normal University,Changchun Jilin 130024,China
  • Online:2025-05-15 Published:2025-06-10

摘要:

健全国家主导的英才教育体系需首先回应好正当性问题。韩国当前关于英才教育正当性的论争主要聚焦三个维度:在英才属性维度,正视才能领域的均衡性、才能程度的差异性及才能发展的动态性,以适应不断丰富的英才内涵;在英才选拔与发掘维度,面对受教育权、甄别工具、本质功能等方面的论争,采取先教育后选拔、合理补偿弱势群体、重视定性选拔与发掘、引导正确认识英才教育功用等举措予以回应;在为英才提供针对性教育与支持维度,通过满足英才群体的差异化发展需要及为弱势英才群体提供补偿性支持,缓和英才群体内部正当性问题。反观韩国经验,我国应从多维理解才能内涵来形成正确英才观、从重选拔转向重教育来建立合理英才教育观、强化补偿性与个性化支持以追求英才教育公平属性这三个方面完善英才教育体系。

关键词: 英才教育, 正当性, 高程度英才, 潜在英才, 韩国

Abstract:

To establish a sound, state-led gifted and talented education system,it is essential to first address the issue of legitimacy. In the Republic of Korea,ongoing debates over the legitimacy of gifted and talented education center around three key dimensions:in terms of the attributes of talented individuals,it emphasizes the importance of recognizing the balance across talent domains,the diversity in levels of talent, and the dynamic nature of talent development, so as to accommodate the expanding connotation of giftedness;in terms of the identification and discovery of talented individuals,the response to debates concerning the right to education,identification tools,and the fundamental purpose of selection includes measures such as prioritizing education before selection,providing reasonable compensation for disadvantaged groups,emphasizing qualitative approaches to identification and discovery,and guiding the public toward a correct understanding of the function of gifted and talented education;in terms of providing targeted education and support,the approach involves addressing the differentiated developmental needs of gifted learners and offering compensatory support to disadvantaged talented individuals,thereby mitigating legitimacy concerns within the gifted population itself. In light of the experience of the Republic of Korea, China should improve its gifted and talented education system in three key aspects: by developing a sound conception of giftedness through a multidimensional understanding of talent;by shifting the focus from selection to education in order to establish a more reasonable approach to gifted and talented education;and by enhancing both compensatory and personalized support to advance the equity dimension of gifted and talented education.

Key words: gifted and talented education, legitimacy, advanced talented person, potential talented person, Republic of Korea

中图分类号: